First of all, I want to say emphatically that YES a virgin stands a better chance.
Like some other people have said, there is no basis for comparison.
So she might just accept whatever she has as the best. Unlike girls that have been with several guys, and have a kind of  FIFA RANKING for all the guys.
The GREAT BOOK also require us to be pure, premarital sex is an impurity.

THAT HE MIGHT HAVE FOR HIMSELF A GLORIOUS CHURCH, HAVING NO SPOT OR WRINKLE,OR BLEMISH.
                                                                                                 
                                                                                                             Ephesians 5    27