Court Orders Minister To Explain How N535m Was Spent On School Feeding During Lockdown

Date: 29-11-2023 8:53 pm (3 months ago) | Author: onuigbo felicia
- at 29-11-2023 08:53 PM (3 months ago)
Online (f)

A Federal High Court, Abuja has ordered Dr Betta Edu, the Minister of Humanitarian Affairs, Disaster Management and Social Development, to release details of how the sum of N535.8 million was expended on feeding of school children during the COVID-19 lockdown.

Justice Nkeonye Maha, in a judgment, directed the minister and the ministry to furnish a civil society group with parts of the information sought in line with Section 25(1) of the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act, 2011.

Justice Maha held that the minister’s failure to respond to the group’s letter dated Aug. 6, 2020 or even give reasons for the refusal to respond to the request as prescribed under the FOI Act contravened the provisions of Section 4(a) and (b) of the act.

“In view of all the matters before me and flowing from the objectives of the FOI Act 2011, the court hereby orders the 1st and 2nd defendants, in line with Section 25(1) of the FOI Act, to furnish the plaintiff with the information sought in Reliefs 3(a), (b), (c), (d),” she declared.

The judge also ordered the minister to comply with the orders of the court within 21 days upon receipt of the orders.

She, however, refused to grant “Reliefs 3(e), (f) and (g) of the plaintiff.”

The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the Incorporated Trustees of Kingdom Human Rights Foundation International had filed the suit marked: FHC/ABJ/CS/1162/2020 following alleged refusal of the then Minister, Hajia Sadiya Umar-Farouq, and her ministry to respond to the information sought.

Umar-Farouq was the minister under the Muhammadu Buhari-led government.

The group alleged that independent investigation and information available to it “revealed that the so-called modified and implemented school feeding programme during lockdown against coronavirus pandemic was a scam, cover-up and well-articulated fiction to embezzle public funds.”

It said that the development was contrary to the statement made by Umar-Farouq during the taskforce briefing on COVID-19 on Aug. 3, 2020.

Therefore, in the originating summons, the group sued the minister, the ministry and the Presidential Taskforce on COVID-19 as 1st, 2nd and 3rd defendants respectively.

Also joined in the suit were the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (SGF) and Independent Corrupt Practice and other related offences Commission (ICPC) as 4th and 5th defendants.

The group sought an order of mandamus compelling the 1st defendant (minister) to immediately release and make available to it all the information and documents requested in its application letter to wit:

Quote
“a. Details, accompanied with documentary evidence of how the N523,273,800 million was spent on school feeding programme during the COVID-19 LOCKDOWN in three states following presidential directive as disclosed to Nigerians by the 1st defendant during the Presidential Taskforce on Covid-19 briefing of Monday, 3rd August, 2020 in Abuja.

“b. Details with the aid of documentary evidence disclosing how the said N523,273,800 million was dispatched/distributed to the 124,589 households whom the 1st defendant claimed received take-home rations valued at N4,200. 00 to wit:”In the FCT, 29,609 households were impacted; 37,589 households in Lagos and 60,391 in Ogun, making a total of 124,589 households impacted between May 14, and July 6. ‘if 124,589 households received take-home rations valued at N4,200, the amount will be N523,273,800.’

“¢. Facts with the aid of documentary evidence, disclosing whether the 124,589 households whom the 1st defendant claimed received take-home rations valued at N4,200 received it in cash or if they received food items.

“d. If the 124,589 households whom the 1st defendant claimed received take-home rations valued at N4,200 received it by cash, facts with the aid of documentary evidence, including state by state photographs of those distributing and those receiving, disclosing whether they were given cash of N4,200 or food items valued N4,200.

“e. Should the 1st defendant claim that the 124,589 households received N4,200 by bank transfer, facts disclosing that the N4,200 was paid into their various bank accounts, including disclosing the bank account numbers of the 124,589 households whom the 1st defendant claimed received take-home rations valued at 4,200 each.

“f. Phone numbers of the 124,589 households whom the 1st defendant claimed received take-home rations valued at N4,200 or the phone numbers of their heads of family.

“g. State by state addresses of the 124,589 households whom the 1st defendant claimed received take-home rations valued at N4,200 to enable the plaintiff immediately confirm if they received the items.”

The group said it instituted the suit in the overall public interest and promotion of rule of law, accountability, probity transparency and strengthening constitutional democracy and good governance.

Responding the minister and the ministry, in their counter affidavit, argued that they did not refuse to provide the information sought as the information had been disclosed in their counter affidavit.

They also argued that information sought by the plaintiff which bordered on addresses and phone numbers of beneficiaries were personal information and that such disclosure was exempted under Section 14 of FOI Act.

They corrected that the total sum was N535, 873, 800 for 127, 789 households and not 523, 273, 800 for 124, 589 as alleged by the group.

They, however, said that they did not disburse cash but food items.

Delivering the judgment, Justice Maha struck out the names of 3rd, 4th and 5th defendants’ from the suit, the plaintiff, having failed to disclose a cause of action against them.

The judge, in the decision delivered on Oct. 30 but the certified true copy (CTC) sighted on Wednesday, said the suit succeeded in part.

She agreed with the argument of the minister and the ministry that the 127, 789 households had not consented to the disclosure of their personal details as required by law.

She also refused to grant the request for the release of bank account numbers of the beneficiaries, having stated that no cash was disbursed.

But Justice Maha held that there was nothing before the court to show how the said food items were disbursed and the defendants had not proved nor shown how the said N535, 873, 800 was distributed to the beneficiaries.

“The 1st and 2nd defendants merely stated facts without proof of how the said sum was allegedly spent.

“All these lapses give room for conjecture and speculation, and the court does not act on speculation; rather on material evidence placed before it,”
she said, citing Section 167 of the Evidence Act.

She, therefore, granted Reliefs (a), (b), (c), and (d) above but declined to grant Reliefs (e), (f) and (g).

Posted: at 29-11-2023 08:53 PM (3 months ago) | Addicted Hero
- gogoman at 29-11-2023 09:52 PM (3 months ago)
(m)
explain!!!
Posted: at 29-11-2023 09:52 PM (3 months ago) | Grande Master
Reply
- Benti247 at 29-11-2023 10:40 PM (3 months ago)
(m)
We don't need any  explanation.  Just  put small  sniper into her food and  force her to eat it. Heartless  people
Posted: at 29-11-2023 10:40 PM (3 months ago) | Gistmaniac
Reply
- ficull at 30-11-2023 01:43 AM (3 months ago)
(m)
She’ll soon say it’s a typo
Posted: at 30-11-2023 01:43 AM (3 months ago) | Gistmaniac
Reply
- maxzy277 at 30-11-2023 06:54 AM (3 months ago)
(m)
Imagine feeding ghosts at schools
Posted: at 30-11-2023 06:54 AM (3 months ago) | Gistmaniac
Reply

fire TRENDING GISTS fire

TODAY'S TOP
  1. When The Time Comes, It Has Come’ – Video Of Mr Ibu’s Last Moment Surfaces

  2. "Hike In Cement Price Has Rendered Us Jobless" - Artisans, labourers Cry Out

  3. 15 Suspects Arrested Over Looting Of Abuja Warehouse

  4. Comedian, MC Pashun Reveals Current Economic Hardship Makes Him Misses Ex Pres. Buhari

  5. HARDSHIP: 'Don’t Repeat It' – Shehu Sani Warns FCT Residents Against Looting Govt Warehouses

  6. Reno Omokri Reveals Reason Many Nigerian Women Will Remain Unmarried

  7. Geometric Power Project: Ikpeazu, Otti Govt At Loggerhead Over Alleged $5m Investment

  8. ‘I Feel Incredibly Privileged’ – Burna Boy Speaks About American City Honour

  9. Police Arrests Driver With Pistol And Ammunition In Edo

  10. Hardship: Tinubu Can't Solve Nigeria's Challenges In 9 Months, Says Umahi

  11. Zamfara Senator, Abdulaziz Yari Set To Distribute 358 Trucks Of Foodstuffs


THIS WEEK
  1. Veteran Nollywood Actor, John Okafor Popularly Known As Mr. Ibu Is Dead

  2. "I Found Out He Was 51 On Our Wedding Day After Telling Me He Was 38" – Mr Ibu’s Daughter

  3. The Real Cause Of Nollywood Legend, Mr. Ibu's Death Revealed

  4. Ogun Serial Ritualist, Adebayo Azeez Reveals How He Gets His Victims From A Dating App (Video)

  5. Kizz Daniel Shows Off His Beautiful Wife As He Teases With New Music “Showa” (Video)

  6. "Late Herbert Wigwe Built State-Of-Art Private Tomb Before Death Struck" – Source Reveals

  7. Video of Late Sisi Quadri Complaining Bitterly About His Health in a Hospital Surfaces Online

  8. VIDEO: Police Parade Fleeing Female Anambra Lawyer Who Brutalized Maid With Hot Knife

  9. “I Want To Die” James Brown’s Sister Gracious Brown Laments Bitterly

  10. “How My Brother Collapsed On A Movie Set” - Sisi Quadri’s Brother Narrates How He Died (Video)


TOP MEMBERS: